With illustration such a big trend this spring (check out UK Vogue's round-up of illustrated cosmetics' packaging, and, duh, Prada's drool-worthy Flower Faerie collection), I couldn't, Carrie "Now On the Big Screen and Thus Totally Relevant in 2008" Bradshaw-style, help but wonder: do fashion's illustrations influence the size debate?
One of the most oft-cited idiotic excuses designers use to defend their choice of wafer-thin models on the catwalks, is some variation on the "curves – breasts and thighs and rounded bits - ruin the line of the clothes"/"the design was perfect on paper, it gets distorted by breasts" etc.
What they're talking about is how the ideal of the design, on paper, works differently when translated into fabric and placed on a real body. Inevitably, when one designs in a 2D paper format, the final result will be different. You're going from a painting to an object. Yet, rather than accept that the finished piece (a dress, skirt, trouser, what have you), is the real design, and the original illustration is merely a piece of artistic whimsy, designers all too often cling to the illustration as the perfect realisation of the design, with the clothing itself a poor facsimile of what could have been.
In a sane world, we would shake our heads and say, "But isn't the point of designing clothes to design, well, clothes? So if you can't design a dress on paper that works well when made, you're not very good at your job. And if you only want to design dresses on paper, go off and be a painter, or a full-time illustrator."
But this is fashion. So instead, as we've seen, we blame the models for distorting the design/ruining the line/stretching the fabric. That's not exactly what I want to examine here: we've discussed designers' wacky views of women's bodies on the catwalk fairly often; let's now move the discussion over to how they imagine women's bodies.
Ever noticed that the women in fashion illustrations have something in common, both with each other, and with catwalk models? Let's take a look:
Ceci n'est pas des femmes
Aside from the issues of race (seriously, where are the non-Caucasian fashion illustrations? Is there some massive shortage of brown ink that we don't know about?), the distortions of illustrated women's bodies are just insane.
It's no wonder designers see a difference between their designs as idealised on paper, and the finished product. It's one thing to add a dash of fantasy to illustrations - they are, after all, an artwork in themselves. But they should be secondary to the real deal, secondary to the reason those illustrations exist in the first place: the clothes.
Yet designers persist in cladding imaginary girls thinner than the paper they're drawn on. I'd love to see the illustrations done by plus designers: Anna Scholz, Marina Rinaldi, et al. Do they, too, whisk their pencil and conjure whippet-thin women, or are their drawings more closely related to the end product?
Do these illustrations matter? Should we concentrate solely on real women, on getting plus-sized models into the magazines and onto the catwalks alongside their thinner colleagues, rather than distracting ourselves with the semantics of cartoons?
I think it matters. Because when you write, or draw, you have absolute freedom. There isn't a client saying, "customers won't respond to an advert with a black model"; or a stylist saying, "fat chicks won't fit into these sample sizes". There aren't real-world, financial implications. Unless you're drawing to commission from a fashion magazine, in which case, are the magazines specifiying "thin imaginary models only, please - and make them white"?
There's just paper, pencil, and imagination. Every race, height, hair colour, size is at your disposal when you illustrate. And yet, even when there are no limits, all we see is thin.
Quick drive-by posting: Kira Cochrane, Women's Editor at my beloved Grauniad, has a new column, The Feminist Dieter.
Personally, I think it's a really brave, honest and quite beautiful piece of writing. You may disagree, but I urge you to read it in full. Extracts:
"And you know what? I didn't mind. In fact, as I started to escape the fug I had been in, looked down and noticed my belly, I realised that being fat was kind of cool. Sure, there were downsides. I no longer looked good in jeans. My bra cups were bigger than my head. My tights rubbed together as I walked, making me sound like a particularly large and irritating cricket. But there were pluses, too.
Most of all, being fat meant that I was suddenly cast out of that uniquely depressing dance that goes on - particularly between women - of policing each other's weight."
"I understand why women engage in these conversations, and why we feel that if we don't apologise for the space we take up, we're afraid that someone else will get in first and cut us down. I understand, too, that for some women these conversations are actually a way of highlighting just how thin they are, thus shoring up their place in some vast unspoken pecking order. And while I find it utterly depressing that a woman would feel that her weight - or lack of it - represents her major achievement, given that we live in a society in which women are, on average, paid 17% less than men, make up only a fifth of MPs, a 10th of leading company directors, and have little choice but to watch in horror as less than 6% of reported rape cases end in a conviction, I can understand why women often don't feel that they or their abilities are really valued, and try to assert whatever small slice of power they can through drawing attention to their body by denigrating it. I understand it, and I don't blame anyone who does it, and I have done it myself, but I also really hate it. It is boring. It is tiring. It is sad."
What do you all think? Also, in other publishing news: remember that hilarious letter in W that we posted about here, where the delightful Coral from Denver explained to us all that fat girls like cookies, but not fashion? Well, Saturday's Guardian (why yes, that is all I read...) Weekend section has that letter's complete opposite, I thought I'd share:
"Is there no end to the bossy misogyny of fashion? Of course not. But Hadley Freeman's comments (Looking Good, February 9) on cleavage are naive, too. Doesn't she realise that if you have big breasts, fashion leaves you no option but to wear cleavage as an act of resistance? Nothing fashion makes either fits a voluptuous figure, or looks nice on it, except for the ubiquitous and by now rather dull wrap dresses. If fashion is so bloody clever, why doesn't it come up with things that look nice on us? Oh, and thanks so much for the subtle reinterpretation of the ancient truth that women with big breasts are stupid. We need reminding - we're so dim it still hasn't sunk in yet."Louisa Young, London W12
Once I started looking for a record deal, I had a trainer. And the trainer told me that I would never sell a record if I didn’t lose weight.
Personally, I sincerely hope she told that trainer off but the very fact that anyone would even say that gives insight into how body conscious the entertainment world is. As intense as the beauty standards for fashion are its easy to sometimes forget that fashion isn't the only industry wherein this pressure exists. The music world enforces its own rules and standards for its female performers. Lately it seems as though the most important thing a singer can do is look "good". With the seemingly endless stream of disposable popstars and drum machine heavy songs more reliant on audio editing programs ProTools than singing talent looks play an increasingly important part in the marketing of music. Reading through the Jill Scott piece I couldn't help but think of this editorial from a few months ago on the importance of sexiness as a marketing tool.
She was an "amazing talent," a young singer with a wonderful voice who wrote beautiful songs. But she was no beauty, plus flat-chested and overweight to boot.
Remembering the aspiring star, music executive Jody Gerson still feels terrible about thinking: "She's never going to get signed, even though she's fabulous."
Its a shame to think just how low actual talent ranks in the scheme of things. How do you feel about stars being asked or told to lose weight in order to secure record deals? I think we can all agree that it is a reprehensible practice but how prevalent do you think it is / can a star succeed if they don't fit the typical cookie cutter?
Back to fashion, I think Jill looks amazing in her red velvet Igigi dress! Absolutely gorgeous - she seems positively regal especially posing on that chaise.
In an average month, I get through ooh, a third of a rainforest's worth of reading material. A couple of papers a day, stacks of magazines a week, books up to my eyeballs, etc, etc. Something struck me recently as I set off for the park with an afternoon's worth of magazines, planning a lazy, sunshiney day of page-flipping and note-taking. Of the wodge of paper I crammed in my bag, three of the issues were weight-related:
Observer Woman (June 2007): The Body Elle US (June 2007): The Body Issue Teen Vogue (June/July 2007): editor's letter and main feature "Weighty Issue"
Let's take them one by one.
Observer Woman
I'm not a massive fan of The Observer's monthly Woman supplement. For those that aren't familiar, The Observer is The Guardian's sister Sunday paper; each week they do a not-that-good flimsy glossy supplement (in addition to the eight billion other Sunday sections) on a theme -- Sport, Food, Music, Woman.
(Hilariously, the three supplements aside from Woman are suffixed Monthly. Sport Monthly, Music Monthly, Food Monthly... one can only assume they wanted to avoid any reference to "your monthlies" and so chose not to call the Woman section Woman Monthly (or Women Monthly, which would make more sense).)
The problem with a Woman supplement is it doesn't really have a coherent theme in the way the other monthly supplements do, or at least the paper hasn't quite decided what exactly Woman is. So it's an awkward hotchpotch of fashion and beauty and fashion and beauty...plus the occasional interview or feature with a Woman of Note. Or a man who works in fashion or beauty. Basically it's a fashion 'n' beauty supplement - and hey, there ain't nothin' wrong with that. Except the paper obviously thinks there is something wrong with that, because Lipstick and Foundation and Dresses and Girlish Fripperies are Shallow; therefore we shall dress them up with the title Woman and throw in the occasional feminist slant to pretend like this isn't Vogue.
So, The Body Issue. It largely avoids the body - there's an interview with Tom Ford, an interview with Anne Sweeney, a list of what's hot or not for summer, lots of writers and peeps sharing their body hang-ups (including - eye-roll - Liz bloody Jones and her body dysmorphia*)...and a very short photo story on swimsuits, featuring four photos of two plus-size models, and an essay on same.
*I'm not making light of actual body dysmorphia. I just hate Liz Jones and think she's old enough to know better. If you're not familiar with this odious excuse for a journalist...ignorance is bliss. Really.
The photos are hot though: "Are you shocked by these photographs? We were - and we commissioned them. We were there, during the shoot. We watched our models, Kate Smith and Elizabeth Satherlund, get transformed, made-up, and styled. We watched them pose. We studied early Polaroids. But still, we were shocked by the finished product. The photographs seemed illicit, transgressive. They seemed overtly sexual. Fetishistic, almost. They certainly seemed contrary to today's rules on glossy-magazine aesthetics. So much bosom! So much bottom! Such luscious rolls of back fat! Such extravagant thighs! Aren't there laws against this?"
Elle
Elle's Body Issue cover star is Jessica Biel, who I haven't actually heard of except in magazines and gossip pictures accompanied by Justin Timberlake. She's totally one of those stars who I know exactly who they are without knowing how or why they got famous. A TV show? A film? Is she a singer? I could IMDb her but then I remember I don't care.
Anyway, the straplines:
THE BODY ISSUE: Love the One You're With
The 6-Step Bikini MakeoverAnyone Can Look Good Almost Naked
How to Lose Those Last 5 Pounds And Why You Shouldn't Bother
"Do I Look Fat In This?" Well... Since You Asked: What Men Really Think
A Little Lipo? What's New, What's Safe
So in order...love your body, but make it over, lose weight by reading these conflicted messages, judge yourself through your fella's eyes, and if all else fails: cosmetic surgery!
No sign of any deviation from the norm in the fashion spreads (in three fashion stories, there are three thin, white, dark-blonde models). There are some interesting stories, but all from the perspective of losing weight and then realising that weight isn't the key to happiness. (The conclusion to these tales is always, hilariously, that the writer discovers it's what's inside that counts, and they have inner peace...inner peace conveniently contained in a newly toned Size 6 bod, but still - inner peace, you guys.)
There's the Mormon who lost 80lbs and had to have her excess loose skin removed by cosmetic surgery, who tells us all about her personal journey and God and wisdom and blah-di-blah...and ends with her gratitude for life and bodies and living: "I can finally say I feel gratitude. Not because I got plastic surgery and look better, but because this is the only body I'll ever have." Okay, then. Betcha you wouldn't have come to that inner-peace conclusion before your four-hour surgery though.
There's the new mother who feels "betrayed" by her body when the excess weight she gained whilst pregnant just won't go away. And by "excess weight" and "just won't go away", she means she gained 45lbs during pregnancy, lost 35lbs of that naturally after the birth through no effort, made some effort to lose the remaining 10lbs...and 'failed' because she still has 5lbs to go. She eventually finds inner peace though, despite that excess weight of...5lbs. (Find me someone who didn't get a few pounds heavier after having had a baby...)
The one article I thought was really interesting was a piece by Walter Kirn basically listing how his ways of seeing had been altered by the women in his life constantly pointing out their flaws to him. I do think it's true that the 'flaws' we see in ourselves and constantly obsess over (my current obsession is that I think my nose has gotten infinitesimally rounder over the last year and is now too wide for my face and needs reducing by 4mm. Really.) are usually not apparent to others.
Sadly Kirn ends with a tale about an ex girlfriend who had "let herself go" and casts "a perfectly oval shadow" (instead of being the petite girl he met and fell for, although since his description of her petiteness involves his not having to move an inch in his seat when she walked in front of him at the cinema, I'm thinking said ex was less "petite" and more "dangerously small," but whatever). After a few digs at her "jumbo bladder" and referring to health issues - even though he's kind enough to say that she was still "mentally sharp under her flab" (yes, really), she dumps him and loses the weight. His conclusion? Not to talk to women when they talk about their bodies. O...kay?
The issue is certainly worth checking out if you're interested, but don't expect to see any plus-size models or valuable arguments.
Teen Vogue
I'll own up to being a total Teen Vogue groupie (teen anything, actually. My long absence from this blog is cuz I'm writing a book on teen television), and am thus likely to defend its every move -- but I'm a groupie for a reason! I genuinely think it has a healthy body image, and is a healthy magazine for young women: it doesn't give the mixed messages (Skinny Stars! Stars Wobbly Bits! Are They Too Thin? Whoops, Stars Ate Too Many Pies!) of a celebby gossip rag, and it features plenty of readers among its pages. There's a good mix of not-too-patronising PSA articles with usefull information, it doesn't preach, and it showcases models and readers of different races and sizes far more frequently than its adult contemporaries on the newstand.
The June/July issue is not a weight/shape/body issue, but it does have an interesting feature on teen attitudes to the whole weight debate. What I enjoyed about it was they had obviously interviewed intelligent articulate teens - but they hadn't stuck just to those teens whose views were safe'. (In other words, they hadn't pre-concluded on the article's behalf, and found teenagers to quote who would say "it's not the magazines' fault, we're all healthy, I like a little cake AND a little exercise!".)
So there are positive quotes:
"I realise they have their body type and I have mine." "Celebrity magazines promote mixed messages." "My friends and I...would rather focus on school."
Iffy quotes:
"I could probably lose a few pounds, but I'm in no rush." (Iffy because we don't know if she could stand to lose a few pounds, but there's also nothing wrong with choosing to lose weight and doing so healthily.)
And down right BUH?! outrageous quotes:
"Being thin is more valuable than money." "America, Jennifer Hudson, Queen Latifah - they're not full-figured. They're fat." "Would I rather be bigger but healthy, or really thin?"
The mag doesn't offer any conclusions, but it's an interesting read nonetheless.
Similarly, I haven't made up my mind yet on any of these issues of magazines, but if you're looking for reading material to kick-start a debate or offer something beyond the usual, you could do worse.
Johanna Dray is one of the loveliest women I've seen in general, even if she wasn't a plus model I'd still be bowled over by her. She's walked for John Galliano, been photographed by Nick Knight and appeared in Vogue Paris. Amazing track record for any model regardless of size. I think this editorial really captures just how glamorous she is. Look at it calls to mind classic beauties like Ava Gardner and Maria Callas, not just in terms of the styling (which is dead on btw) but just in terms of her general presence and allure, her face just leaps off the page. There has been a lot of late 40s - early 50s redux cross culturally lately (here's to you Dita Von Tesse) but Johanna's presence in this set really elevates it above the usual retro fare. How fabulous that Galliano dress on her? Its absolutely stunning. It was great when she wore it on the runway but its even better editorially. I'm also really loving that Dietrich tux complete with white oxfords and bowtie. Just looking at this set makes me want to turn on TCM and catch up on classic Hollywood fare.
Miss J opened the TFFF discussion on magazines with her review of Vogue's Shape Issue. Magazines love to dress their "real life readers". Rarely does an issue go by without a feature on dressing to suit your shape, or making the most of your best bits. What's interesting about those features is what those best bits supposedly are.
Often they'll choose a trend, say a colour or a particular silhouette, and do a What to Wear If You're...Tall, Skinny, Petite or Plus. (They rarely accommodate a shape that combines two or more of those things. What if you're tall and plus, or petite and plus, hmmm?)
Some magazines do it brilliantly: Seventeen, for instance. I have an old issue next to me, from August 2004. The cover headline is "Clothes For Your Shape & Budget". At first you're worried it will be another case of dressing the plus girl in jeans and a long-length tunic top to cover her 'faults'. Instead, inside you find lots of cute readers wearing different looks, labelled according to trend, not size. A plus-petite girl next to a tall-curvy, or a skinny-petite next to a plus-tall. Not a shape label in sight.
Teen Vogue from November of that year is great, too: cute outfits, in all sizes, with no lecturing, and fun pull-quotes like "On me, knee-length skirts fall below the knee. So of course I love minis!" Trust me, as a 5'3" munchkin, I know whereof this girl speaks.
I will give the teen mags credit - they might use the same ol', same ol' slim models, but they do feature a wider range of sizes and looks than their adult counterparts. And I love that their What To Wear... pieces rarely show you step by step, size by size - instead they mix it all up and provide plenty of options, for you to make your own mind up.
No, the problem comes when magazines do makeovers or show readers how to adjust looks and trends to their figure 'problems'. I've been searching and searching for pertinent examples, but despite owning a houseful of magazines dating back a decade, I just can't. I tend to throw any issues I'm anti into the recycling, never to darken my doorstep. But y'all know what I'm talking about, right?
They'll show a plus-size reader she too can wear a mini-dress....so long as she covers up her problem legs with jeans! Want to wear the trendy It dress? Well, you CAN'T - unless you wrap those upper arms in a shawl! Steer clear of tight clothes...short clothes...flesh-exposing clothes...
It doesn't just apply to the plus-sizes, either. Skinny, flat-chested lasses are told to make the most of their little waists and arms...but heaven forfend they should rock their non-existent cleavage. Tall girls must wear layers and blocks of different colours to 'break up' their height. Short women shouldn't wear maxi or layers because it will reveal that they are - horrors - short.
The What To Wear... pieces always focus on the negative, indeed they invent negatives. Who says a rounded tummy is a flaw? What's wrong with looking tall if you are in fact tall? Why should thighs that rub together stay under wraps, along with bingo wings? I'm all for accentuating the positive, but that's rarely what magazines do.
The focus on plus-sizes wearing trends is never, hubba hubba come to mamma, did you see those boobies? It is your solemnly sworn duty to wear this scoop-necked dress with this bra and present your breasteses on a platter. Or it's not, good gracious, ass is bodacious! Take these butt-accentuating skinny jeans and corset, and show the world what you're going to do with all that junk inside your trunk. No, it's always, cover that belly! hide yourself! away, away with this flesh!
Do do this. Don't do that. Avoid this is you're this and that if you're that. C'mon. We can dress ourselves, you know. I've been doing it for 25 years! Okay, I've been doing it for 25 years minus the years my parents did it, and minus the years I had to be forced, kicking and screaming, into Clothkits dungarees when I really wanted to run naked like a butterfly (um, a butterfly with legs) through the garden before eating some mud.
But really - I love a bit of style advice, or a friend to tell me what works, or a magazine to offer solutions to certain issues. I wish I'd had a magazine to advise me not to wear my teen favourite outfit of maroon crushed velvet elasticated waist tube skirt + green hand-knitted jumper + unlaced converse + giant sunflower + floppy hat like Six from Blossom, but then I wouldn't have the memories. Ah, sweet memories.
What I do have a problem with is people telling me, and others, that our figures are problems. That your butt is not, as I thought, a wonderful playground wherein Matthew McConaughey may play the cheeks like bongos, but a thing to be hidden; that big juicy thighs or arms or indeed any body part are not wonderful, ripe, rich, firm lovely goodies, but flaws to be disguised.
The only flaws of mine I will ever try and disguise are pimples and my giant ego.
(Ooh, speaking of my ego - let me pimp my latest article for The Independent!)
After months of media attention US Vogue has finally weighed in on the Skinny model debate. I've been waiting for this article for some time now. It seems every other publication from People to Paper has had something to say on the subject but Vogue has remained silent. Its no surprise that the magazine that launched the careers of some of the most lanky and lithe models on the scene would wish to chose its words carefully amidst growing public concern about the dangerous of anorexia and other eating disorders within the fashion world but silence is by its nature damning. Especially considering the very human cost of questionable practices within the fashion world.
The article itself Walking A Thin Line by Rebecca Johnson attempts to address eating disorder issue within the modeling world while praising the veritable cult of thinness. This is simply put a mistake. Statements like "clothes look better on a thin person" don't illustrate anything aside from the authors own feelings about models. When last I checked different clothes looked better on different people, it isn't about fat vs. thin its about what suits you and what works for you. Saying that clothing looks better on any one body type is counterproductive and ultimately damaging.
Underlying biases aside some valid points were touched such as the veritable banishment of heavier models to commercial work. After the fall of the supermodel any girl over a size 0 is either out of a job or regulated to swimsuit and lingerie work (an issue we'll touch more on later) they become the dreaded c word. Commercial. Its an unspoken yet widely accepted rule within fashion that once a girl gains weight she loses her edge (I suppose they mean the razor sharp edge of her sunken cheekbones) and subsequently her blue chip clients. Its always been a bit disconcerting to me that the look of health and happiness in a girl is somehow considered unfashionable. Weight is not merely a physical issue for models its a monetary one as well. The vast majority of girls on the catwalks today are underage, away from their families and attempting to be breadwinners. Even a small change in size can leave a girl out of work. Take the case of Dutch model Doutzen Kroes, a stunning girl by any standards and yet she was sent home from a Gucci casting for being too "fat".
This is Doutzen by the way.
Her words on the subject:
"I like the Versace show best so far. The collection is really beautiful and at Versace femininity is important. Feminine shapes are allowed. In contrary to Gucci where I got rejected because I was too fat! Gucci likes slim girls only." - Doutzen Kroes
I know. It boggles the mind that her shape is considered unacceptable.
Its this incredibly skewed perspective that Ms. Johnson never truly touches on. For all the soundbytes from designers and snippets about the CFDA forum no one ever outright says that the ideal laid in place has become unattainable. Impossible even. When 6ft tall 100lb teenagers are being asked lose weight something is incredibly wrong. Robin Givhan of The Washington Post alludes to the problem:
"I think what happened was our eyes changed slowly over time...After a while, a size 0 starts to seem normal, not cadaverous. Fashion is about fantasy and aspiration. Women look to it for inspiration. But somewhere along the way the industry went from long and lean to something you wouldn't want to aspire to. It became unattractive."
What she doesn't say is that it also became dangerous. Luisel Ramos and Ana Carolina-Reston died because they tried to force their bodies to submit to an ideal of perfection that doesn't exist and for every girl that loses her life tragically there are so many more who suffer in silence.
I can't help but think that part of the problem lies in the devaluation of the girls themselves. Gone are the days when models were viewed as individuals whose unique beauty highlights the clothing, today with the exception of a handful of well known girls they are just nameless faceless human hangers. There is a good quote on this within the piece:
"When the models themselves were famous designers would gladly alter a dress to fit the girl. But when the models are generically interchangable, its easier to find a girl who fits the dress."
In other words we can cut as small as we want and if you don't lose weight to keep up were not going to hire you.
And what of the solution? How can this problem be solved or at the very least dealt with? Based on the interviews it would seem that the main course of action seems to be finger pointing. Designers blame bookers, bookers blame models and Gisele blames parents. No one wants to take responsibility and everyone is too busy searching for a scapegoat to truly address the issues at hand. I was especially offended by the very end of the article wherein genetic science was brought up. Genetic components of any disease notwithstanding I felt as though that was a giant cop out. Yes diseases are inherently tied to our genes but I don't feel as though what's going on with the fashion industry can be explained away by placing the blame on DNA. It would seem that people are really reaching for any and every excuse to deflect blame away from the inherent problems within the industry.
In short the Vogue article left me with little more than a bad taste in my mouth. Its been months since the deaths of Luisel and Ana and nothing has changed. Isn't about time we placed more importance on the lives of young girls than on scraps of fabric? And not just the lives of models but the lives of all the young girls and women who look to fashion for inspiration because this is not JUST a fashion issue. If the BMI system does not work there ought to be a a search for a system that does work. Putting down a few fruit platters backstage is not enough, its time for a shift in the way beauty is presented and viewed. If the samples are too small make them bigger. If the girls look ill send them to talk to doctors/nutritionists and get counseling and if the clients only want frail emaciated young women tell them to get real and understand that beauty isn't about squeezing into a negative size sheath.
I fear I am rapidly becoming the misanthropic yin to Miss J's delightful yang, as here I go again with another negative story. In contrast with her sunny tale of the beautiful Crystal Renn appearing left right and centre looking radiant, I bring you this week's award winner in the Most Idiotic Journalism Prize.
With apologies for the poor image quality - I don't have a scanner so this is merely a digital photo of the newspaper:
The photo is of supermodel Kate Moss - I think it's a clear enough picture to see that she looks no different from usual, and actually better, since she's lacking that useless appendage known as Pete Doherty - on the front cover of the London daily newspaper, The London Paper. This is a free broadsheet distributed from around 3 pm every weekday near tube stations, train stations and office buildings, sort of the evening equivalent to the long-standing morning Metro. Launched in the autumn, its rival is the London Lite; both papers are laying claim to the Evening Standard's territory, a newspaper retailing at 50p per copy (95 cents), and readership - the thousands of London commuters who need a read and some city-centric news to get them through the long train journey out of London, or the equally long tube/bus journeys within the city. The two London papers, Paper and Lite, have fast become a familiar site on the city's transport system, with dozens of copies littering the trains and platforms. Each copy is read, on average (based on entirely unscientific observation of my fellow passengers...) by five different people.
Anyway, that long-winded explanation out of the way (as if none of you can possibly grasp the concept of a free newspaper - apologies for my patronising waffle), let's address the subject of this post. The headline, in that wee purple box there, reads A TRICK OF THE LIGHT?
The text goes like this:
Millions of women can allow themselves a satisfied smile today at the sight of Kate Moss on a Caribbean photoshoot looking decidedly chunky-thighed. The 33-year-old was in St Barts for a shoot with New York jewellery company David Yurman.
Let's address this point by appalling point. Before we even reach the "chunky-thighed" comment, which would be vicious, unnecessary and hateful enough even if applied to someone with actual chunky thighs, we have that bastion of lazy writing, the concept of women hating women. This kind of writing comes from the same Big Book O' Cliches as "girls just want to have fun!" and "tired of sneaking your expensive purchases into the house? Try shopping during a footie match. Your man won't even notice that Selfridges bag during the big game!" - it's 'tee-hee, aren't women shallow and silly' writing disguised as news.
Do you watch, wait and pounce for other women to slip up and be seen chunkier of thigh, bigger of hip, rounder of belly? Do you smirk in satisfaction when women are photographed looking rounder than usual? Do you chortle at the pages of Heat and People - see how they've helpfully placed a red ring around the stars' cellulite, to save you the bother of reaching for your red marker pen! Does waiting for the day Reese Witherspoon look anything less than perfect keep you up all night? Don't you long for the day her bottom sags? I’ll bet you do - and when it does, you'll invite the girls round (1) for a bottle of wine (2) and some choccies (3) to have a good laugh (4) at the gruesome pics (5).
Wow, I just crammed five female-unfriendly clichés into one sentence. That must be some kind of record...I hope the prize is a staff writing job at Loaded magazine! Women only have female friends and refer to other women as "girls"; we bond by drinking and having (horrible term) 'girly nights' (2); where we eat chocolate because (a) girls love chocolate! and (b) we're happy and healthy and can indulge with 'treats' every now and then for fun! (3); we spend lots of time laughing at these get-togethers, because women rarely socialise for work or serious talks or discuss art or literature - it's all about fun with the girls! (4); and fun with the girls means laughing at other people's looks (5). Which isn't to say I'm a miserable teetotal bore who never reads Go Fug Yourself, but is more to point out my utter boredom with women's journalism which seems to categorise our entire gender as living their lives as a chick flick montage cliché.
My point, if you remove the dripping layers of sarcasm, is that women aren't actually 'satisfied' by other women failing (I'm temporarily ignoring Moss's incredible figure) to adhere to rigorous beauty standards. I might be a fashion and beauty writer but shockingly I'm not quite so shallow as all that. I don't have a tick list of hatred: Kate Moss gains weight, check! Liv Tyler's hair goes frizzy, check! Kate Winslet photographed without make-up, check! Heat publishes close-up of reality TV starlet's spots, check! You just won Misogynist Bingo - collect your prize of Trim-Spa at the door!
What would satisfy women, or a large majority of us at least, is: equal pay; access to free and impartial contraceptive advice and healthcare; the right to work and the right to bear children - at the same time; safety in our personal and professional lives; redress for wrongs against us; freedom from discrimination on account of our gender...y'know, wacky stuff like that. I suspect we'd also raise a smile at these other things, to name a few at random: an end to patronising journalist clichés that set us up against each other and paint an entire gender as at war with itself; an end to judgement of the body beautiful and the dangerously narrow aesthetic pervading our culture; plus-size clothing available everywhere as the norm and not as special collections; freedom to exist in our bodies and do as we please with our them; and an end to the forced myth that our only happinesses are derived from each others' misery.
That's point one. The next time I catch sight of anything so offensive as "millions of women can allow themselves a satisfied smile today" in the city's daily newspapers I'm organising a London-wide boycott of the London free press. Also....allow? ALLOW? ALLOW??!! I don't need permission to be satisfied or to smile; I certainly don't wait for some badly produced free newspaper to print pictures of a beautiful woman whom they deem unacceptably large before I allow myself to be happy.
The word choice here is appalling: allow. As if we must be rigorously self-disciplined, on 24-hour watch to make sure we don't gain weight or our hair grow roots or our moustaches go unbleached; we must be constantly on guard, exercising here, eating bean sprouts there, shopping for illegal diet pills on the internet, cutting out pictures of our ideal bodies, always working, working, working, and sweating and worrying and punishing, never letting up for fear that we might fail and be soft or round or slack or less than perfect, until - oh thank god for the day when we can relax, for others among us have fat thighs too.
Let us rejoice, let us smile, let us celebrate with a low-fat sugar-free non-dairy dessert, for today is a glorious day, today is the day when a thirty-something supermodel is pictured in a swimsuit looking mildly different from her nineteen-year-old self, oh happy day! All our rights are won and we may rest easy tonight, satisfied and smiling...correction, allowed to be satisfied and smiling, because someone else has failed in the 24/7 war against their bodies.
Point two. Without disregarding anything said previously, or suggesting in any way that the photograph caption would be acceptable if it were accompanying a plus-sized woman or a woman who had gained a significant amount of weight: take a look again at the photograph the newspaper is using to illustrate this pointless - front page! - story. I defy you all to spot the chunky thighs they are talking about. In actual fact, I think this cover would be less dangerous if it was referring to a plus-sized girl. It would be as offensive, sure, but in using Kate Moss, an incredibly small woman, to illustrate 'chunky-thighed', the piece suggests her figure in this photo is the very upper limit to which we are allowed to let ourselves go.
Anything less - or, more pertinently, anything more - than this is unacceptable. This is how low and unattainable the barrier is in the media. That is as fat as your thighs must get before we will attack you. Do not allow, do not give yourself permission, deny yourself the right, to live inside the body you have. Perhaps I am overreacting to what is, after all, a tiny puff-piece on a slow news day, on the cover of a free city newspaper, with a circulation of less than half-a-million. Perhaps we can let these little battles go, because we have bigger wars to fight. Perhaps I am over-dramatising a photo caption that few will see and fewer bother to consider.
Or perhaps it is this endless, pervasive, corrosive drip drip drip of mean, petty, divisive, cruel commentary, that we see daily, in our city newspapers, our national newspapers, our magazines and blogs and films and commentary, that is the heart of the problem. Perhaps we cannot win the bigger fight until we first address the culture that this war on our bodies arises from - a culture that takes a tiny piece from us day by day by day with comments like this, that surrounds us and mires us in negativity about our natural state, until we are convinced we are nothing, until we have no strength left, until we cannot allow ourselves to fight.
There are different ways of seeing. John Berger said that "Seeing comes before words. The child looks and recognises before it can speak." But after you have words, you see differently.
I wrote on this site recently about the need to unlearn our skewed aesthetic. How, when confronted over and over with bodies of a certain type, and size, we begin to see them differently. And how further, when these are the only bodies we see, other sorts of bodies begin to look different, wrong somehow, almost grotesque.
It seems so obvious to say. But whilst it's easy to acknowledge, intellectually, that our ways of seeing bodies have been skewed by the bodies we've seen, it is harder to emotionally realise it. Case in point: Heroes has just begun in the UK. I think we're up to episode three, where the cop's wife shows up. The cop is played by Greg Grunberg, who in the scheme of things is a bit of a chubster (cute, though). His wife is played by Elizabeth "Lisa" Lackey, formerly of Home and Away. She's an ex-model, perfectly lovely, but not a teeny tiny toned tiny thing - she has boobs and a faint, cute belly. She's woman-shaped. And my brain said, "ah, like husband like wife - it's the fatty family".
It's ridiculous. I know body fascism and the cult of thin is wrong and fucked up, and the obsession with petite actresses, where anything over 5'1" and 100lbs is 'big', is appalling. But my brain has learned something else and it's so bizarre to me, that however much feminist theory I read and subscribe to and however much I intellectually stand for something, there's bits of my brain that I have no control over, because my ways of seeing have been warped.
This is Lisa Lackey:
Just because she’s not Ellen Pompeo-d herself out of existence, I called her fat. (Crazy, when if this was someone I knew, a friend or a relative, I'd be envying her figure all over the place. But when it's someone on TV or in a magazine, I have, against my will, expectations that they will be a certain size, a certain look.) Speaking of Pompeo, she shares the screen with Katherine Heigl, who again, is normal...wait, not normal. She is, in the words of the show, "eight feet tall. Your boobs are perfect. Your hair is down to there. If I was you I would just walk around naked all the time. I wouldn't have a job, I wouldn't have any skills, I wouldn't even know how to read. I would just be... naked."
Katherine Heigl is, basically, a goddess. But next to her co-star it's easy to read her as 'enormous' because comparatively she is twice Pompeo's size. It's easy to see her slight underchin that the camera adds on and decide that she is 'fat'. I know which of the two figures is more natural, more healthy, and more easily achieved by the average woman...but for some reason it's so difficult to emotionally understand it, to really KNOW that Size 0, 2, 4, etc aren't the norm, aren't the only way of being beautiful.
I've learned to see petite as normal and anything bigger than that as 'unfeminine', as if femininity was natural and not a societal construct. Show leads are often very petite - not merely slim or thin but tiny overall. Think Sarah Jessica Parker in Sex and the City, Sarah Michelle Gellar in Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Kristen Bell in Veronica Mars, Rachel Bilson in The O.C., and dozens of others. They are tiny. Not just thin women, but tiny overall. Teeny tiny child-like women. And naturally, any normal-sized actor on the screen looks hulking in comparison.
"When I worked at Vogue a decade ago, one of the editors produced a beach-shoot featuring a size-14 model [nb. this would be a US size-10]. When they arrived in the office, the photos looked great; the model was statuesque, not overweight. But later, on the published page, tucked in between other shoots and ads featuring the starving Barbaras that are the usual glossy fodder, this lovely woman looked huge, as if she'd been inflated with a bicycle pump. No wonder the experiment wasn't repeated. No wonder Sophie Dahl shrank the moment she made it as a model. Given the choice, we'll take thin, thanks."
Why can we know something and not see it? Is it the prevalence of thin and small women on-screen and in magazines, with so few representatives of other body types? Or is it something more, that in addition to what we're being shown, we're being told something.
Claire Coulson, Daily Telegraph Fashion Editor
"In pictures and on the catwalk, clothes hang much better on very slender girls."
"Clothing looks more tantalising on tall, slim women."
(Daily Express, February 14 2007)
Katharine Hamnett, Designer
"This is so frivolous. Obviously it's tragic for families of anorexics. My bone of contention is that the industry should be ethical and environmental. Clothes look good on thin people and they always have. We weren't having this size zero debate when Twiggy was around.
"Clothes look better on thin people and rubbish clothes look good on thin people. Thin people look good in anything. Don't you think that it is an indictment of an obese society? That's what it is, because we are all fat and think somebody thin is special. It's what's wrong with our society. It isn't just the fashion industry."
"Models have to be skinny - that's the point. The job is to be a clothes horse and everyone knows the clothes look better on the catwalk on a thin model. No one wants larger girls to show off their clothes; it looks a bit silly."
People genuinely believe what they're saying; people believe clothes look better on the thin, the slim, the tall. I sometimes believe it, even though I 'know' differently. How have we learned to see this way, and how do we learn to see differently? One cover girl or one plus-size model isn't enough, because they will automatically look 'wrong' set amongst other bodies of a thinner type.
I'm trying to unlearn what I've seen and what I've heard. I was a life model for a very long time and that helped in giving me an incredibly strong body confidence: I don't look at my own body and see a flabby disaster area, or compare myself to catwalk models or film stars; I see myself as 5 feet two inches and 130 pounds of fabulosity. Yet I look at other women and judge them for bodies 'better' than my own, just because those bodies are different from the 'best'. I'm content with my own little pot belly and big booty, but I judge other women for not controlling theirs, for not having the discipline to be thin. And it does take discipline: I can be, and have been, twenty pounds lighter and two sizes smaller. But all I thought about was food, all I thought about was exercise. It takes up hours of each day that I'd rather spend writing, working, reading, socialising, shopping...to be thin if you are not naturally so is hard work and dominates your life. Yet a part of me judges women if they don't put in that hard work.
Two things that I'm trying to keep in mind, to unlearn what I've learned, to help me see differently, to help me stop listening to what I'm told about thin and fashion:
Maggie Alderson, former UK Elle editor and fashion writer
"The Princess [Diana] was a great comfort to us ageing babes, too. The closer she got to forty, the better she looked. On one of her last publica appearances, in that tomato-red shift dress, she looked her best ever, glowing in her maturity. I miss that. When fashion magazines are full of malnourished fourteen-year-old girls, sometimes you need reminding just how beautiful grown women with real baby mama tummies are."
and of course, Pulp Fiction:
Fabienne: I was looking at myself in the mirror. Butch: Uh-huh? Fabienne: I wish I had a pot. Butch: You were lookin' in the mirror and you wish you had some pot? Fabienne: A pot. A pot belly. Pot bellies are sexy. Butch: Well you should be happy, 'cause you do. Fabienne: Shut up, Fatso! I don't have a pot! I have a bit of a tummy, like Madonna when she did "Lucky Star," it's not the same thing. Butch: I didn't realize there was a difference between a tummy and a pot belly. Fabienne: The difference is huge. Butch: You want me to have a pot? Fabienne: No. Pot bellies make a man look either oafish, or like a gorilla. But on a woman, a pot belly is very sexy. The rest of you is normal. Normal face, normal legs, normal hips, normal ass, but with a big, perfectly round pot belly. If I had one, I'd wear a tee-shirt two sizes too small to accentuate it. Butch: You think guys would find that attractive? Fabienne: I don't give a damn what men find attractive. It's unfortunate what we find pleasing to the touch and pleasing to the eye is seldom the same.
There are other ways of seeing. I'm not going to stop looking at fashion magazines and beautiful models; but I hope I'm going to look, and see, other things properly too. It's unfortunate what we find pleasing to the touch and pleasing to the eye is seldom the same. Maybe we can relearn what we see and how we see it, and maybe what we find pleasing to the touch can become pleasing to the eye.
TFFF welcomes the newest member of our team the divine Olivia, reporting straight from London Fashion Week, giving us the scoop on all things Brit. Here she sounds off on British Vogue's response to the skinny model debate.
Vogue vs. Logic by Olivia
So farewell New York Fashion Week, and hello to Le Fwuh, as I am so wittily calling LFW. We kick off on Sunday with Paul Costelloe , the off-schedule kicks in on Monday, and Marc by Marc Jacobs sees us out next Friday. London has three free daily newspapers and all the national papers are based out of London, so naturally with Fashion Week around the corner the size zero debate is gearing up for round two and we are surrounded by headlines and debate.
Vogue (UK March issue) has a six-page feature on the issue, which prevaricates between admitting that the industry is deeply flawed, and pretending like everything's okay because fashion is their business, and it is a business .
On Wednesday we saw that even famous faces are not exempt from the problem. When one talks of models and eating disorders and dying from being too skinny, one thinks of the more anonymous models, ones that the fashion-obsessed might know of but Joe Public can't put a face or a name to. The average girl can't name a Luisel Ramos or an Ana Carolina Reston until they see the names in a news story on model deaths. However they can probably recognise, if not name, Natalia Vodianova, Daria Werbowy, Gemma Ward and Lily Cole because they have contracts for major perfume, beauty and high street campaigns that reach even the non-fashiony person. If 'name' models haven't the power or status to be whatever weight they care to be, what hope less powerful models? The only possible exception is Kate Moss, but she is an exception to just about every rule.
Kate will never die from being too skinny. She might die from: cocaine / Pete Doherty contracted STDs / exhaustion / overexposure / choking on her own vomit, but not from starving herself. She is by no means a healthy woman nor one with a high BMI. But she's also Kate Moss. Her nose is caving in; she lost every contract going after her nose candy parade; she is not looking good; she's phoning in her recent campaigns and yet...mo' money is not leading to mo' problems with La Moss. She's untouchable, and should any designer be fool enough to say "Katie, honey, lay off the pies would you sweets?" she could have them killed.
At a recent London College of Fashion debate chaired by Alexandra Shulman, featuring Roland Mouret and Lily Cole, the subject of "zoinks -- models sure are thin!" arose. Mouret explained that in a catwalk show, to ensure nothing distracts from the clothes, the clotheshorses have to be uniform in size and appearance. (Hence the identical hairstyles and make-up looks designed for a show.) I can understand Mouret's point, but why must that uniformity be based around thin?
There is a certain impact to be had with uniformity. Remember this?
Linda. Cindy. Naomi. Christy. Same size, same shape…supermodels. Just watching this video shows how strange and unattractive size zero really is. Viva la 1990s!
One of Vogue's arguments is that designers simply can't afford to make more than one size of each sample. Let me just dissect that for the bullshit that it is:
ONE. If you can barely afford to make samples, and are making just one of each look, why must the sample size of choice be a 2, 4, 6, 8 decision? Alberta Ferretti makes sample clothes in a UK 10, US 6. I'm fairly certain the fabric of society (and her clothes) has not been torn asunder by this and designers could go further and make 12s or 14s. (I'm talking in UK sizing here.)
TWO. If we're talking haute couture and the gown is sewn by blind seamstresses in Paris ateliers out of woven unicorn hair and gilded with the tears of orphans, perhaps you can only afford to make one.
But I've seen a lot of sample clothes. (See, stroked, coveted, contemplated stealing.) Very often, extraordinary design aside, they are ordinary. Worn by model after model after model and steam cleaned daily and flown hither and thither, within a few weeks they begin to disintegrate. They are made for two shows, a dozen shoots and a few personal appearances, not for sale.
Samples are sturdy, but -- crucially -- not precious. The finished clothes may end up costing $7,500 in the shops but the sample is not worth that money. Yes, it costs more to make two. But that cost is: (a) not twice the cost of the finished product when it becomes available to buy, because that's not how samples work, and (b) what cost is worth women's mental and physical health?
THREE. Since for most fashion houses the clothes do not make the profit -- it comes from the key-chains, the bags, the shoes, the perfumes -- losing a little money on a sample cannot reasonably make a difference. Launch a diffusion perfume and bang! money recouped.
FOUR. New designers are sponsored by enterprises like Lulu Kennedy's FashionEast or Topshop's NewGen. If corporations are prepared to pay to put on a show, they should be prepared to pay for as many sample sizes as it takes. Topshop makes a mint out of its associations with high fashion and new designers; they have the cash to splash to make larger samples. They owe it to their customers.
Vogue says: "Hollywood should ask itself about the body image it promotes and the size it insists upon; yes, magazines such as Heat are unhelpful; yes, there is a hypocrisy when newspapers moralise about the dangers of skinny models, only to print photographs of them at their skinniest, alongside purposefully unflattering pictures of celebrities who have put on weight". It goes on to point out that Vogue does not employ models who are under 16 and thus haven't reached their adult weight. In other words: look, we made a concession! And say, lookit all these other factors we can blame! Vogue rulez ok! Etc.
There is certainly more than one factor to blame, and we have all learned new ways of seeing, unconsciously or not, from magazines and television, that make certain healthy sizes look 'fat' to us, and we have to unlearn these. But aside from who to blame and why this is happening, I have another question. Not "why thin?" or "why fat?" or "who's to blame?". But this: why women? London Fashion Week begins tomorrow. Let's see if it brings any answers.