|
|
The Independent on Sunday yesterday carried a story in their news section on the new size acceptance, citing Adele, Marina Rinaldi, the size 16 winner of the Surrey heat of the Miss England competition, and the monthly online magazine Just As Beautiful. (Is it sour grapes to harumph about poor journalism by saying they totally should have mentioned Too Fat For Fashion...?) Have a read, and, as ever, let us know what you think.
Spangly designer Julien MacDonald, famous for his orangey skin, sparkly dresses, and delight in dressing nubile young starlets in bum-grazing dresses on the red carpet, dressed Gossip singer Beth Ditto for the BRIT Awards last night:  What do you think? Personally I'm not a fan of MacDonald's chandelier chic (and not just because I've never gotten into one of his shows...), but it's great to see a 'name' designer reintepreting his work for a plus-size icon, and Beth looks fabbity.
Quick drive-by posting: Kira Cochrane, Women's Editor at my beloved Grauniad, has a new column, The Feminist Dieter. Personally, I think it's a really brave, honest and quite beautiful piece of writing. You may disagree, but I urge you to read it in full. Extracts: "And you know what? I didn't mind. In fact, as I started to escape the fug I had been in, looked down and noticed my belly, I realised that being fat was kind of cool. Sure, there were downsides. I no longer looked good in jeans. My bra cups were bigger than my head. My tights rubbed together as I walked, making me sound like a particularly large and irritating cricket. But there were pluses, too.
Most of all, being fat meant that I was suddenly cast out of that uniquely depressing dance that goes on - particularly between women - of policing each other's weight." "I understand why women engage in these conversations, and why we feel that if we don't apologise for the space we take up, we're afraid that someone else will get in first and cut us down. I understand, too, that for some women these conversations are actually a way of highlighting just how thin they are, thus shoring up their place in some vast unspoken pecking order. And while I find it utterly depressing that a woman would feel that her weight - or lack of it - represents her major achievement, given that we live in a society in which women are, on average, paid 17% less than men, make up only a fifth of MPs, a 10th of leading company directors, and have little choice but to watch in horror as less than 6% of reported rape cases end in a conviction, I can understand why women often don't feel that they or their abilities are really valued, and try to assert whatever small slice of power they can through drawing attention to their body by denigrating it. I understand it, and I don't blame anyone who does it, and I have done it myself, but I also really hate it. It is boring. It is tiring. It is sad." What do you all think? Also, in other publishing news: remember that hilarious letter in W that we posted about here, where the delightful Coral from Denver explained to us all that fat girls like cookies, but not fashion? Well, Saturday's Guardian (why yes, that is all I read...) Weekend section has that letter's complete opposite, I thought I'd share: "Is there no end to the bossy misogyny of fashion? Of course not. But Hadley Freeman's comments (Looking Good, February 9) on cleavage are naive, too. Doesn't she realise that if you have big breasts, fashion leaves you no option but to wear cleavage as an act of resistance? Nothing fashion makes either fits a voluptuous figure, or looks nice on it, except for the ubiquitous and by now rather dull wrap dresses. If fashion is so bloody clever, why doesn't it come up with things that look nice on us? Oh, and thanks so much for the subtle reinterpretation of the ancient truth that women with big breasts are stupid. We need reminding - we're so dim it still hasn't sunk in yet." Louisa Young, London W12 Louisa, honey, I think I kind of love you.
It's good news Friday here at TFFF HQ! The British actors' union Equity has been approached by a model coalition asking to join. That's right, kids: modelling is going unionised.  United we stand, divided we fallApparently some major, major names have signed up -- but sadly they don't yet want to be identified. Rocking the boat in the fashion industry -- which isn't exactly union-friendly -- is still difficult. But how great is this? Maybe it's because I'm from a union family, but I think this is excellent news. We've long discussed the difficulties inherent in changing modelling conditions, and some have put forward the idea of a models' union. Models have agencies, sure, but each girl has a different agent -- and they're just there to find work, not necessarily ensure conditions are fair. Because modelling is so individualised, and very often it's a one-model-per-shoot situation, they're separated from their peers, and inevitably find it difficult to stand up for their rights: for health and safety, fair wages, heck, even a lunch break. Let alone the real issue: what size they're 'allowed' to be. I'm not suggesting that we'll see the union and the industry sit down for talks and hash out a specific weight requirement that will satisfy both parties, because that's crazy talk: but we might see a move towards models having the power, a move towards sample sizes being made to fit the models, and not the other way around. Because really: cutting fabric to fit a girl makes so much more sense than shrinking a girl to fit the fabric. Martin Brown, a spokesman for Equity, had this to say: "Models have no voice; no one is listening to them and no one is asking them what they want. We were approached earlier this year by a group of models who said they needed a union. They complained they had no one to represent them and that if something went wrong and they went to their agencies they were warned not to complain because they would not work again."
We here at Too Fat For Fashion love us some J.Hud, so when we heard this quote, from the Avon Foundation Gala earlier this week, we had to share it: "I have the height of a model, the breasts that people pay for and the lips that everybody wants, so why should I change? I wouldn’t change myself for anything or anybody. That will never happen." It kind of reminds me of that fabulous Grey's Anatomy quote (back when the show was still good and zeitgeisty, okay?!) from Cristina: "You are eight feet tall. Your boobs are perfect. Your hair is down to there. If I were you I would just walk around naked all the time. I wouldn't have a job, I wouldn't have any skills, I wouldn't even know how to read. I would just be... naked." Jennifer Hudson showing off the figure in question. No news yet on fashion credits -- if anyone knows the designer behind these fab dresses please email TFFF at the usual address!
Forgive me readers, for I have sinned: the beauty of the blogosphere (aside, obviously, from the word "blog" which I like to use as often as possible in the hopes that somehow, somewhere, Anna Wintour will cry out in pain and she won't know why) is that you can update round the clock, bringing readers the fashion news even before it has happened. Yet here we are and I think the last update from your Euro correspondent was way back in the mists of time...when Rachel Zoe still had representation, when Professor McGonagall still had hopes that Albus would one day see what lay beneath her stern robes, when it wasn't so flipping cold. Mea culpa. However please accept a number of delays between now and December as I struggle to complete my magnum opus on teen television. I hope to cast aside such worthy issues as "does Dan Scott from One Tree Hill use hair straighteners?" and "isn't Canada too cold for people to frolic al fresco like I'm seeing on Falcon Beach?" every now and then to bring you various fashion tidbits from across the pond. Penelope Cruz for Spanish fashion label MangoLike today's subject, inspired by a piece from The Independent, all about the Spanish fashion industry and standardised sizing on clothes: Following years of complaints from frustrated consumers, the Spanish government has acted to bring order to the chaotic disparity of clothes sizes. The socialist health ministry, which has responsibility for consumer affairs, has struck an unprecedented deal with big Spanish retailers, manufacturers and trade associations to standardise clothes sizes and end consumer confusion.
...
Last month technicians from Spain's health ministry visited the first of 59 towns across the country to measure 10,415 Spanish women, aged between 12 and 70, to find out what size and shape the nation's females really are.
...
The aim is to promote "a realisable image of healthy beauty – neither Rubens women nor anorexic girls", according to the health minister, Bernat Soria. "It is our commitment that beauty and health go hand in hand."The article goes on to note that the standardised system will also include promises from retailers to size up their window mannequins to at least a UK 10 (US 6), and to incorporate size UK 18 (US 14) into all ranges rather than treating it as a 'special' size and hiding it away. It might sound like only a tentative move towards body acceptance, but UK 18 is one size larger than Topshop and many other uber-fashionable high street brands. Short of a bloody revolution and overthrowing the ateliers, or something, I think moves like this -- one step, or size, at a time -- are the way we're going to get progress in the industry. The thrust of the article is less about the irritants of being one size in one store and another in another (annoying though that is, you eventually get to know your Size Per Store), and more about the negative effects differing sizes can have on body image. I can't speak for every Brit, but one of the delights of shopping in the US for us is -- aside from the strong pound and everything being totally cheaper anyway -- going down two sizes. Sometimes we'll buy stuff just to waft around and be all "I'm size 8!" It's less fun shopping in continental Europe and coming out with a size 44 or whatever (not least because I really don't understand what that is). I have to assume that it's something metric that makes no sense compared to our thoroughly simple system of sizing things in pints, guineas and shillings. Hastily constructed and not necessarily accurate size converter.It's just too much. Like why do France and Spain go from a 46 to 50 in one sizing step? Just to be difficult and, y'know, French? What's with Japan going for the odd numbers? If S starts that low, do plus sizes end up being called XXXXXXXXL? Because that will look silly on the label and make nobody happy. And don't even get me started on Gap doing that annoying Sizes 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, etc. Size 3 isn't a size! Soylent Green is people! I'm actually wearing right now: a Gap vest, Size S/P (?!), a Primark cardigan, Size 8-10 (so...in between sizes?), and Stella McCartney for Adidas track pants, Size 12 (the only label that gives a conversion to all other sizes, except, weirdly, the US).* Number-number style sizing I can cope with, up to a point, for stuff like cardigans or whatever -- if they're not meant to be fitted, I guess a random one-size-fits-several attitude is acceptable. Plus it's Primark. BUT 'S/P' IS NOT A SIZE. *I'm at home and it's cold and I'm poorly! Please don't judge me on this mishmash. Am I alone? Do y'all find yourself wandering around stores just utterly perplexed and guesstimating the size? Feeling crappy when you go up two or four numbers? I do think that using numbers or graded size words plays into this: would one strive for a size zero if it were called something else? And as pointed out above, if you start sizing S at a UK 10, you pretty quickly run out of options except to just keep adding Xs in the manner of the stalkery love notes I write to Bryan Greenberg until he gets a restraining order, um, you can't fit any more on the label. I personally think the fashion industry needs to steal a leaf from the food industry's book (perhaps playing speedknob on it, and writing 'I smell' for good measure, then flicking its pigtails), and, following Spain's lead, standardise the lot. Perhaps not worldwide, but cutting a swathe across continents so you can flit between, say, London, Paris and Milan buying up a storm without having to carry a calculator. As each country's population has changed a great deal, and differently, measuring 10,000+ women seems a good place to start in drawing up the new sizing. (If they can also make bra manufacturers stick to the same sizing chart, I and my boobs would say a hearty thank you also.) Then when they're done measuring and cutting and sticking and drawing and deciding, (you know, the all powerful 'they'), a system that doesn't involve ever increasing numbers or judgey words would be super. I'd far rather be a size green or a size fabulous than a size 12 anyway. How great would that be? Not only are you the same size in every store, but it's a positive (if totally random) word, that bears no relation to any other size words. So instead of having people sniffle that they're now a size delicious and need to diet back down to size effervescent, they..wouldn't.
The New York Times has an interesting article this week about the Danza Voluminosa, a troupe of plus sized dancers changing attitudes about dance in Cuba.

The prima ballerina of the Danza Voluminosa troupe weighs 286 pounds, and as she thumps gracefully across the floor, she gives new meaning to the words stage presence. Her body is a riotous celebration of weight — of ample belly and breasts, of thick legs and arms, of the crushing reality of gravity. I thought the article was intriguing - the world of dance (particularly ballet) is one of the most body conscious fields in existence, the idea of an all plus-sized troupe is quite daring. I honestly can't recall ever seeing a dancers on stage who weren't very lithe. I found the opinions of the dancers themselves to be very open and honest - they all seemed to feel as though they were struggling with their weight and expressed concern about that but at the same time they felt uplifted by their ability to use the power of dance to empower themselves and others. For the dancers, working with Mr. Mas has changed their lives. Several said they suffered from constant embarrassment and guilt over their weight before they began dancing. But dancing has taught them to accept, if not love, their bodies. They also say that after a performance, they feel self-esteem that is foreign to most them, having suffered from the gibes of their peers since childhood.
Barbara Paula, 29, who weighs 275 pounds, has been dancing with the troupe for five years. She said it still felt strange at times to be on stage, as if she were constantly discovering the potential beauty hidden inside her body, which for years was a source of shame for her.
“It’s something new,” she said. “I don’t have this complex anymore that because we are obese, we cannot dance, we cannot walk in the street.” Full NYT Article Admittedly I do not come from a dance background so perhaps someone could speak more on the subject of body politics within dance? I'd be quite interested to hear opinions or experiences with regards to that. Special thanks to Rosa for sending me this article
Another fashionable designer is doing plus sizes! So-Cal designer Rachel Pally has teamed up with Nordstrom to produce a plus sized line. From WWD Rachel Pally, the Southern California contemporary designer who believes that well-cut jersey flatters all women, is teaming with Nordstrom to launch a plus-size line filled with Empire-waist dresses, wide-leg trousers and her other signature looks for the fall.
 A taste of Rachel's signature styleI've really enjoyed Rachel Pally's clothes for awhile now they have that great laid back vibe that L.A. designers just seem to inherently possess. Her clothes also have a reputation for being incredibly comfortable which is always a plus. Nothing is worse than a pretty dress thats a pain to wear. I'm hoping that the Nordstrom's collection will be high quality and full of colorful options just like her straight-sized line. Thanks to Medina for the heads up about this!
This yoghurt advert is to me like ice-cream to Dawson's dad...Reading Feministing, I came across this post. Apparently there's a series of adverts for a diet yoghurt that uses iconic images of women, like this --  -- and replaces the original skinny version with a plus-size woman. The caption reads "Forget about it. Men’s preference will never change. Fit Light Yogurt." (Thanks to joelle once again.) Apparently after you finish retching in disgust at the hideous fatty, you then rush out and buy some diet yoghurt to make sure you remain attractive to men and diet yo'self down to the original skin'n'bones version. Apparently, it's 2007. Her milkshake brings all the boys to the yard...However, I must now edit, because another dairy-licious thing arrived in my inbox today. To balance out the hideousness of that advert, I bring you the super-sexy fantastic Sara Ramirez. Who has got milk, and got curves, and got It:  Sara Ramirez: bringing me and dairy back together since ought-seven.
As you may have heard the flagship outpost of web favorite Monif C is opening in NYC this week. Two plus boutique openings in the NYC area in less than a month? Amazing! The opening event will feature a special sale so tri-state area girls check it out! Grand Opening Event: Thursday June 14, 2007 7 - 10pm Come shop the Monif C. line at 20% off, cocktails, music, personal shopping tips, and more! Monif C. Plus Sizes New York Plus Size Boutique Store 325 W. 38th Street (bet. 8/9th aves.) Suite 1007 New York, NY 10018 Open Monday - Saturday, call 212-842-1641 for hours
Great heads up from our friend Lisafashinista at Beauty Plus Power. Lee Lee's Valise a plus sized boutique specializing in fashionable plus sized clothing is opening up in Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn! The boutique will carry Elena Miro, IGIGI, Tadashi, Donna Ricco, Kiyonna, B & Lu and a host of other incredible plus sized brands along with special services like on site alterations! You really can't beat that with a stick. Tomorrow is the Grand opening for any and all who wish to check it out. I will personally be there with bells on. Lee Lee's Valise Grand Opening Event
Saturday May 5th 1pm - 8pm 368 Court Street (at the corner of President St)
Take the F or G train to Carroll Street Station and walk 1 block 718-246-LEES
I interrupt your regularly scheduled TFFF for a couple of reasons. One is entirely to baste my ego, much like a turkey, and another is to give you some news of plus-sizes in the media, although not strictly fashion related. First, let me brandish this turkey baster and fill it with the sweet liquid goodness of blowing my own trumpet, to badly mix a metaphor or two. I had my first fashion piece published last week in British newspaper The Independent, which means that when you read TFFF you can rest easy in the knowledge that we are a website run by professionals. (Ha! My professionalism barely amounts to getting to work on time.) Anyway, I have a few more commissions coming up that I shan't bore you with in future, but since the article was in the features Extra section - and thus didn't go online - I thought for this first one at least I would bore you with a scan. (A bad scan, at that, since the paper is bigger than the scanners at my college, so the headline and picture is cut off. But my utterly brilliant words are there for all to see!) Click the glowstick to see my article!  The second piece of news I wanted to share was from another British paper, The Guardian, who have commissioned Gossip's Beth Ditto as their newest columnist. Beth will appear fortnightly in G2 (the features-based supplement to the main paper) in their Women section, dispensing advice to those who ask for it. Her opening column is here. I love this quote: People still sometimes comment on the way I look, but at this stage they can't tell me anything I don't already know. I know I'm fat, I know I'm quirky, I know my teeth are yellow. I do actually have access to a mirror, so this hasn't got past me. When people say things like that, I just feel like saying - "Duh?" Or, "Wow, you're a genius, you should be a photographer. You have such impeccable vision." Her first piece of advice relates to coming out to colleagues. Nothing to do with fashion, but everything to do with fat politics, and having more plus-size women in the media is a definite (no pun intended) plus.
British magazine New Woman (or NW according to recent rebranding), conducted a survey of 5,000 readers about body size and image. The results are horrible and disturbing: 97% of those surveyed consider a UK Size 12 fat [US Size 8].1 in 8 took illegal drugs or medications to aid slimming.59% thought Size Zero was attractive.58% believe that men find Size Zero a turn-on.97% of those surveyed prefer to go out with friends who are 'fatter than them'.3% said that they were 'happy to have thinner girlfriends'.76% were 'jealous' of their thinner friends.94% said they have 'felt fat before a night out'.50% say 'they go without food all day'1 in 10 said that they 'make themselves sick so they can fit in a dress'1/3 have tried to survive on less than 500 calories a day.6 in 10 said their friends have criticised their body shape.4 in 10 say their mothers urges them to lose weight.73% said they 'can't eat normally and stay a size 12 or less'.48% 'pretend they've eaten when they haven't'.1/5 claim their colleagues make jibes about their size.84% said they would be happier if they could lose weight.2/3 said they think about their size every 12 minutes.37% have resorted to slimming pills.1/5 said they had taken laxatives to shed unwanted pounds. The 'most wanted' body shape was Liz Hurley's - a woman who once said "I maintain my figure by eating very little breakfast, not too much lunch. Then only tiny little snacks in the day. I'm on a good old-fashioned low calorie diet - I'm going to bed hungry." The second was Victoria Beckham.
 L-R: Liz Hurley, Victoria Beckham.You can see the full 100 list here. NW's editor Helen Johnston said: "Elizabeth Hurley is the British body icon - pencil slim but still curvy, the perfect shape most women desperately want.
"However, ordinary women can comfort themselves with the fact it's a 24 hours a day job, requires iron determination and probably very little food.
"For most of us, a body like Elizabeth Hurley's would require a lifetime of sacrifice.
"Victoria Beckham is frequently criticised for her body size, but it seems British women are obsessed with her shape and wouldn't hesitate to swap their body for hers. Women think she looks good." So far so reasonable. She goes on to say: "We all understand the anxiety of going out with a drop-dead gorgeous skinny mate who gets all the attention and leaves us feeling like her fat invisible friend.
"And there's nothing worse than knowing whatever you wear your slimmer friend is always going to look better than you do." Emphasis mine. I sort of understand what Ms Johnston is trying to say here, but her choice of phrasing merely reinforces the myth that slim looks 'better' and that beauty is not subjective. A slimmer friend is always going to look different to you, and in some eyes that difference is better, but Johnston's phrasing is a little off. I think the 'Size 12 is fat' stat. is the most important of all these results. The rest of the statistics are about unhappiness with weight, trying to change your weight, going to extremes to do so...presumably to avoid the dreaded Size 12. It seems to me if you can change the Size 12/Fat attitude, you can change the other problems. (It's no 'save the cheerleader, save the world', but still.) For the record, I can demonstrate what a UK Size 12 looks like, because I am one. I didn't want to illustrate this with a celebrity picture because someone's specific dress size is, frankly, anyone's guess. So here we go. I am 5'3", I weigh between 130 and 140 pounds at any given time, currently I'm 135. I wear a Size 12 in the majority of stores. I am smaller than the UK national average of Size 16. And according to this survey, I am fat: Dress Christopher Kane for Topshop, £110 from Topshop. Neon footless tights, £5 from Topshop. Neon earrings, £2.99 from Topshop. Bangle, vintage.Apologies for the blurry picture quality, but I think, I hope, you can see that (questionable nu rave fashion choices aside) a Size 12 is not so terrible. Size 12 it is not something one should be abusing laxatives and drugs to avoid. Nor do I think there is any upper size limit that you can point to and say, 'this is where fat begins', and it's terrifying that the women surveyed not only think that, but (a) set the fat-bar pretty low, and (b) go to extreme lengths to stay beneath it. (On a separate note, how awesome is Christopher Kane? Love love love his stuff.) I don't really read NW - I've picked it up occasionally, but not recently since they have this irritating environmental thing going on where they call women who care about the environment "eco sluts" - as a positive thing. So shopping pages might feature one organic item and it would have a little star on it saying "eco slut buy!" and I'm not a big fan of calling women sluts, and don't really see why they need to 'sex up' green politics, so...don't ever buy it. Not really sure what their demographic is, nor how they conducted the reader survey. I wonder whether we would get the same or similar results from a Vogue or Elle - dedicated fashion magazines - or other magazines with different demographics? Or a nationwide survey? Do the majority of women think this way? Or is it - as our friend Coral from Denver might have it - a certain type of woman who considers me fat? ( Source)
Everyone is probably aware by now that Donatella Versace's daughter Allegra, 20, is seriously ill with anorexia. The British press have gone wild with this and are busy making up statements and digging up past Versace scandals in the hope of painting the family as some sort of Italian version of the Kennedys.
 Donatella & Allegra VersaceTFFF wanted to give you the news, but at the same time we feel this is a delicate subject and shouldn't be used for an editorial. Allegra is just 20 years old, and whilst she is in the public eye this is not through choice; even were she someone who had courted the press, we feel commentary on the Versace family's difficult situation is inappropriate and tasteless. Versace are expected to release an official statement later today requesting privacy, although they have not released any kind of press statement yet as far as TFFF are aware, so any quotes you may have read are more than likely to have been fabricated. This is a really sad story and I don't want to use it to write another fash-bashing editorial, because really, I think this is just awful news. TFFF sympathies are with Allegra and her family.
A super-short post, just to say that I was reading the March issue of W, and came upon this letter: I don't think there's any need to enlist more robust models in your fashion magazine. After all, I don't think the type of women who purchase the clothing you show are size 10s. I've passed up a lot of cookies to fit into my skinny jeans, and I want to see how garments are going to drape on a size-2 body like my own. CORAL STEVENSON, DENVER, COLO. That's right ladies: if you're a size 10, you probably (a) are a certain type of woman - because women are two types, fat or thin; (b) don't buy fashionable clothes, because fat lasses love the muumuus; and (c) it's all your own fault anyway, you greedy, cookie munching giantess. Where's your willpower?! Thanks, Coral from Denver! And by 'thanks' I mean 'fuck you'.
I fear I am rapidly becoming the misanthropic yin to Miss J's delightful yang, as here I go again with another negative story. In contrast with her sunny tale of the beautiful Crystal Renn appearing left right and centre looking radiant, I bring you this week's award winner in the Most Idiotic Journalism Prize. With apologies for the poor image quality - I don't have a scanner so this is merely a digital photo of the newspaper:
 The photo is of supermodel Kate Moss - I think it's a clear enough picture to see that she looks no different from usual, and actually better, since she's lacking that useless appendage known as Pete Doherty - on the front cover of the London daily newspaper, The London Paper. This is a free broadsheet distributed from around 3 pm every weekday near tube stations, train stations and office buildings, sort of the evening equivalent to the long-standing morning Metro. Launched in the autumn, its rival is the London Lite; both papers are laying claim to the Evening Standard's territory, a newspaper retailing at 50p per copy (95 cents), and readership - the thousands of London commuters who need a read and some city-centric news to get them through the long train journey out of London, or the equally long tube/bus journeys within the city. The two London papers, Paper and Lite, have fast become a familiar site on the city's transport system, with dozens of copies littering the trains and platforms. Each copy is read, on average (based on entirely unscientific observation of my fellow passengers...) by five different people. Anyway, that long-winded explanation out of the way (as if none of you can possibly grasp the concept of a free newspaper - apologies for my patronising waffle), let's address the subject of this post. The headline, in that wee purple box there, reads A TRICK OF THE LIGHT? The text goes like this: Millions of women can allow themselves a satisfied smile today at the sight of Kate Moss on a Caribbean photoshoot looking decidedly chunky-thighed. The 33-year-old was in St Barts for a shoot with New York jewellery company David Yurman. Let's address this point by appalling point. Before we even reach the "chunky-thighed" comment, which would be vicious, unnecessary and hateful enough even if applied to someone with actual chunky thighs, we have that bastion of lazy writing, the concept of women hating women. This kind of writing comes from the same Big Book O' Cliches as "girls just want to have fun!" and "tired of sneaking your expensive purchases into the house? Try shopping during a footie match. Your man won't even notice that Selfridges bag during the big game!" - it's 'tee-hee, aren't women shallow and silly' writing disguised as news. Do you watch, wait and pounce for other women to slip up and be seen chunkier of thigh, bigger of hip, rounder of belly? Do you smirk in satisfaction when women are photographed looking rounder than usual? Do you chortle at the pages of Heat and People - see how they've helpfully placed a red ring around the stars' cellulite, to save you the bother of reaching for your red marker pen! Does waiting for the day Reese Witherspoon look anything less than perfect keep you up all night? Don't you long for the day her bottom sags? I’ll bet you do - and when it does, you'll invite the girls round (1) for a bottle of wine (2) and some choccies (3) to have a good laugh (4) at the gruesome pics (5). Wow, I just crammed five female-unfriendly clichés into one sentence. That must be some kind of record...I hope the prize is a staff writing job at Loaded magazine! Women only have female friends and refer to other women as "girls"; we bond by drinking and having (horrible term) 'girly nights' (2); where we eat chocolate because (a) girls love chocolate! and (b) we're happy and healthy and can indulge with 'treats' every now and then for fun! (3); we spend lots of time laughing at these get-togethers, because women rarely socialise for work or serious talks or discuss art or literature - it's all about fun with the girls! (4); and fun with the girls means laughing at other people's looks (5). Which isn't to say I'm a miserable teetotal bore who never reads Go Fug Yourself, but is more to point out my utter boredom with women's journalism which seems to categorise our entire gender as living their lives as a chick flick montage cliché. My point, if you remove the dripping layers of sarcasm, is that women aren't actually 'satisfied' by other women failing (I'm temporarily ignoring Moss's incredible figure) to adhere to rigorous beauty standards. I might be a fashion and beauty writer but shockingly I'm not quite so shallow as all that. I don't have a tick list of hatred: Kate Moss gains weight, check! Liv Tyler's hair goes frizzy, check! Kate Winslet photographed without make-up, check! Heat publishes close-up of reality TV starlet's spots, check! You just won Misogynist Bingo - collect your prize of Trim-Spa at the door! What would satisfy women, or a large majority of us at least, is: equal pay; access to free and impartial contraceptive advice and healthcare; the right to work and the right to bear children - at the same time; safety in our personal and professional lives; redress for wrongs against us; freedom from discrimination on account of our gender...y'know, wacky stuff like that. I suspect we'd also raise a smile at these other things, to name a few at random: an end to patronising journalist clichés that set us up against each other and paint an entire gender as at war with itself; an end to judgement of the body beautiful and the dangerously narrow aesthetic pervading our culture; plus-size clothing available everywhere as the norm and not as special collections; freedom to exist in our bodies and do as we please with our them; and an end to the forced myth that our only happinesses are derived from each others' misery. That's point one. The next time I catch sight of anything so offensive as "millions of women can allow themselves a satisfied smile today" in the city's daily newspapers I'm organising a London-wide boycott of the London free press. Also....allow? ALLOW? ALLOW??!! I don't need permission to be satisfied or to smile; I certainly don't wait for some badly produced free newspaper to print pictures of a beautiful woman whom they deem unacceptably large before I allow myself to be happy. The word choice here is appalling: allow. As if we must be rigorously self-disciplined, on 24-hour watch to make sure we don't gain weight or our hair grow roots or our moustaches go unbleached; we must be constantly on guard, exercising here, eating bean sprouts there, shopping for illegal diet pills on the internet, cutting out pictures of our ideal bodies, always working, working, working, and sweating and worrying and punishing, never letting up for fear that we might fail and be soft or round or slack or less than perfect, until - oh thank god for the day when we can relax, for others among us have fat thighs too. Let us rejoice, let us smile, let us celebrate with a low-fat sugar-free non-dairy dessert, for today is a glorious day, today is the day when a thirty-something supermodel is pictured in a swimsuit looking mildly different from her nineteen-year-old self, oh happy day! All our rights are won and we may rest easy tonight, satisfied and smiling...correction, allowed to be satisfied and smiling, because someone else has failed in the 24/7 war against their bodies. Point two. Without disregarding anything said previously, or suggesting in any way that the photograph caption would be acceptable if it were accompanying a plus-sized woman or a woman who had gained a significant amount of weight: take a look again at the photograph the newspaper is using to illustrate this pointless - front page! - story. I defy you all to spot the chunky thighs they are talking about. In actual fact, I think this cover would be less dangerous if it was referring to a plus-sized girl. It would be as offensive, sure, but in using Kate Moss, an incredibly small woman, to illustrate 'chunky-thighed', the piece suggests her figure in this photo is the very upper limit to which we are allowed to let ourselves go. Anything less - or, more pertinently, anything more - than this is unacceptable. This is how low and unattainable the barrier is in the media. That is as fat as your thighs must get before we will attack you. Do not allow, do not give yourself permission, deny yourself the right, to live inside the body you have. Perhaps I am overreacting to what is, after all, a tiny puff-piece on a slow news day, on the cover of a free city newspaper, with a circulation of less than half-a-million. Perhaps we can let these little battles go, because we have bigger wars to fight. Perhaps I am over-dramatising a photo caption that few will see and fewer bother to consider. Or perhaps it is this endless, pervasive, corrosive drip drip drip of mean, petty, divisive, cruel commentary, that we see daily, in our city newspapers, our national newspapers, our magazines and blogs and films and commentary, that is the heart of the problem. Perhaps we cannot win the bigger fight until we first address the culture that this war on our bodies arises from - a culture that takes a tiny piece from us day by day by day with comments like this, that surrounds us and mires us in negativity about our natural state, until we are convinced we are nothing, until we have no strength left, until we cannot allow ourselves to fight.
Sara at Dressr Blog draws TFFF's attention to the latest high street hypocrisy. UK uber-chain Topshop approached The Gossip to do a series of in-store gigs, presumably to capitalise on singer Beth Ditto's current status as It chick: ever since music mag NME voted Ditto the coolest person in rock, she's been the go-to gal for a dose of insta-cool. The idea, as with most Topshop non-fashion collaborations, would presumably have seen posters and images of Beth Ditto scattered around the London flagship store, lending a little punk cool cachet to the increasingly mainstream store.  The move has backfired, with Ditto pointing out the hypocrisy of Topshop wanting to capitalise on The Gossip's cool factor...without expanding their brand to provide clothes that the singer could ever wear. Since the chain is not averse to design collaborations with non-designers - hello, Kate Moss! - there's no reason the store could not have asked for a Gossip gig or two together with a design collaboration or consultation on a plus-size line. Ditto's response: Give me the job. I want to design, I want you to make clothes for big girls, big boys, I want you to make big sizes. I don't want just your money or the cred of hanging out with Kate Moss, which is fine, but it's not want I want in life. I want more. I want what she gets.
I don't think it's fair to put my face somewhere where they would never let me in there to wear their clothes. If they want our music they've got to actually do something to earn it. I can get money anywhere, I don't need your money unless you're going to do it my way.
They don't want to dress people that look like me, that have a normal body, a bigger body, whatever. I mean I don't really know why they want The Gossip to do things for them, I don't understand because if they saw me in the street they'd never give me the time of day. One of the major reasons Beth Ditto has been so hailed as "cool" (whatever THAT means) has been her non-conformity: much of her press cites her weight and size, focussing on her success and sexiness as a fat girl. That Topshop wanted to purchase some positive PR without taking the whole package -- 'hey, we'll have the music, the fans with purchasing power, the face and name...but, wait? Provide clothes bigger than a size 16? Ew.' -- is both hilarious and tragic. Hilarious that Philip Green thought he could get away with it and Ditto would sign up, tragic that he thought he could get away with it...and you know he's not going to be introducing a plus-size line any time soon. * * * In response to comments about my Giles Deacon for New Look piece, I'm happy to issue a correction: New Look do have a plus-size line, Inspire, in UK sizes 16-26. I still stand by my main point, that special collaborations like the Gold by Giles line, should be available in plus sizes too, in keeping with the concept of increasing accessibility to designer pieces. * * * In other random news: food products are soon set to carry their carbon footprint on packaging. A packet of crisps will show a 75g carbon stamp, indicating the total carbon footprint from every level of production. Great news in the food industry: onw what about fashion? I can't wait for the day this is extended to the clothing and accessories industry. Cotton is one of the biggest producers of carbon, and with clothes often manufactured in several different countries - a label here, a button there, a pattern cut here and flown elsewhere to be finished, before flown to yet another country to be sold - fashion is one of the most important industries in environmental terms. Whilst we're campaigning for more ethical values viz. sizing in the industry, let's extend those ethics to all areas. Being able to buy a size 22 in Topshop would be great - even greater if it carried its carbon footprint (and even better if that footprint was as low as possible).
British broadsheet nespaper The Guardian had an interesting piece yesterday in its G2 section (think the fun, comic-sized features accompaniment to the hard-news of the main section). It reprinted an article first seen in the newspaper in 1924 when The Guardian was still The Manchester Guardian. Read the text in full here. Ignoring the hilarious tone of the writing, which talks of "the required slimness" and "the everlasting high heels" and note that it concludes with the idea that the fashion for slenderness is...healthy. A case of plus ca change, plus ca la meme chose, or are the times a-changin', since now it is more or less acknowledged that ultra-thin is ultra-scary? (Albeit in the same publications that then use the ultra-thin models and samples in their shoots...)
|
|